Tweet
CHRISTIANS FEUD OVER CHURCH OF HOLY SEPULCHER
By Matti Friedman
Associated Press
Monday, 27 Oct 2008, 12:27 PM CDT
JERUSALEM -- Two rival monks are posted at all times in a rooftop
courtyard at the site of Jesus' crucifixion: a bearded Copt in a black
robe and an Ethiopian sunning himself on a wooden chair, studiously
ignoring each other as they fight over the same sliver of sacred space.
For decades, Coptic and Ethiopian Christians have been fighting
over the Deir el-Sultan monastery, which sits atop a chapel at the
ancient Church of the Holy Sepulcher. The monastery is little more
than a cluster of dilapidated rooms and a passageway divided into
two incense-filled chapels, an architectural afterthought alongside
the Holy Sepulcher's better-known features.
And yet Deir el-Sultan has become the subject of a feud that has
gone far beyond the walls of Jerusalem's Old City. The Ethiopians
control the site, but the Egypt-based Copts say they own it and see
the Ethiopians as illegal squatters.
The quarrel has erupted into brawls -- in 2002, when the Coptic monk
moved his chair into the shade and too close to the Ethiopians, a dozen
people were hurt in the ensuing melee. And today, the Ethiopians claim
the fight could result in the monastery's collapse and even in damage
to other parts of the church, one of the holiest sites in Christendom.
Since the 1970s, the Israeli government has refused to allow
renovations or significant repairs at the disputed monastery until
the Ethiopians and the Copts come to terms. That hasn't happened,
and the Ethiopian Church says the years of neglect have put the
structure in danger. The Copts suggest the Ethiopians are merely
trying to further cement their hold.
The Ethiopian Church commissioned a report from an Israeli engineer
backing up its claim, and in early October the Ethiopian patriarch,
Archbishop Matthias, asked the Israeli government to carry out urgent
repairs. The archbishop attached the engineer's assessment that the
humble monastery structure could collapse -- and possibly damage the
chapel below -- if steps are not taken to repair it.
The report, compiled by Yigal Berman of the Milav engineering firm,
cited "safety hazards" that "endanger the lives of the monks
and the visitors," according to a report in the daily Haaretz
newspaper. Yifredew Getnet, a spokesman for the Ethiopian Embassy
to Israel, confirmed the report. A committee made up of embassy
representatives, churchmen and lay leaders has been appointed to
oversee the monastery, he said.
Outside the monastery, Coptic monk Antonious El-Orshlemy said his
church owns Deir el-Sultan, and that the Ethiopian claim that the
monastery is about to collapse is false.
"The building is very fine, and not dangerous to someone," he said.
The most recent round of the feud began in 1970, when Ethiopian
monks changed the locks while the Copts were at services on the eve
of Easter and moved in.
The Ethiopian Church has six monasteries and 70 monks in the Holy Land,
according to the office of the patriarch. A handful are stationed
at Deir el-Sultan. The main parts of the Holy Sepulcher are divided
between the Catholics, Armenians, and Greek Orthodox.
Three years before the Easter takeover, Israel captured the Old City
from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast War and found itself in charge of
the Holy Sepulcher.
The Copts appealed to an Israeli court, which ruled that the
Ethiopians should not have altered the fragile status quo at the
church but said it was the government's job to decide what to do. The
government decided not to take action, according to Daniel Rossing,
director of the Jerusalem Center for Jewish-Christian Relations and
an expert on the city's fractious religious mosaic.
International politics likely played a role in the decision:
At the time, Israel had warm ties with Ethiopia and was at war
with Egypt. Later that was reversed: Communists came to power in
Ethiopia and cut ties with Israel, and Egypt and Israel signed a
peace agreement. But Israel still did not act, possibly because of
concerns that angering Ethiopia could hamper the emigration of the
country's Jewish community.
Feuds like the one over Deir el-Sultan "don't have a solution, period,"
Rossing said. "The trick, then, is to do the very best job to make
things as livable as possible, within the limitations of never being
able to solve these issues."
Israel's interior minister, Meir Sheetrit, now plans to mediate
the dispute, and the government will help renovate the site as soon
as the sides can agree on a course of action, said spokesman Ilan
Marciano. But with each side entirely rejecting the other's claim to
the monastery, it is unclear if an agreement is possible.
The feud is only one of a bewildering array of rivalries among
churchmen in the Holy Sepulcher, where each group remains on guard
against any encroachment onto their turf. Fights have flared over
issues such as who is allowed to sweep which steps, and Israeli police
occasionally intervene.
The Israeli government has long wanted to build a fire exit in the
church, which regularly fills with thousands of pilgrims and has only
one main door, but the plan is on hold because the sects cannot agree
where the exit will be built. In another example, a ladder placed on
a ledge over the entrance sometime in the 19th century has remained
there ever since because of a dispute over who has the authority to
take it down.
By Matti Friedman
Associated Press
Monday, 27 Oct 2008, 12:27 PM CDT
JERUSALEM -- Two rival monks are posted at all times in a rooftop
courtyard at the site of Jesus' crucifixion: a bearded Copt in a black
robe and an Ethiopian sunning himself on a wooden chair, studiously
ignoring each other as they fight over the same sliver of sacred space.
For decades, Coptic and Ethiopian Christians have been fighting
over the Deir el-Sultan monastery, which sits atop a chapel at the
ancient Church of the Holy Sepulcher. The monastery is little more
than a cluster of dilapidated rooms and a passageway divided into
two incense-filled chapels, an architectural afterthought alongside
the Holy Sepulcher's better-known features.
And yet Deir el-Sultan has become the subject of a feud that has
gone far beyond the walls of Jerusalem's Old City. The Ethiopians
control the site, but the Egypt-based Copts say they own it and see
the Ethiopians as illegal squatters.
The quarrel has erupted into brawls -- in 2002, when the Coptic monk
moved his chair into the shade and too close to the Ethiopians, a dozen
people were hurt in the ensuing melee. And today, the Ethiopians claim
the fight could result in the monastery's collapse and even in damage
to other parts of the church, one of the holiest sites in Christendom.
Since the 1970s, the Israeli government has refused to allow
renovations or significant repairs at the disputed monastery until
the Ethiopians and the Copts come to terms. That hasn't happened,
and the Ethiopian Church says the years of neglect have put the
structure in danger. The Copts suggest the Ethiopians are merely
trying to further cement their hold.
The Ethiopian Church commissioned a report from an Israeli engineer
backing up its claim, and in early October the Ethiopian patriarch,
Archbishop Matthias, asked the Israeli government to carry out urgent
repairs. The archbishop attached the engineer's assessment that the
humble monastery structure could collapse -- and possibly damage the
chapel below -- if steps are not taken to repair it.
The report, compiled by Yigal Berman of the Milav engineering firm,
cited "safety hazards" that "endanger the lives of the monks
and the visitors," according to a report in the daily Haaretz
newspaper. Yifredew Getnet, a spokesman for the Ethiopian Embassy
to Israel, confirmed the report. A committee made up of embassy
representatives, churchmen and lay leaders has been appointed to
oversee the monastery, he said.
Outside the monastery, Coptic monk Antonious El-Orshlemy said his
church owns Deir el-Sultan, and that the Ethiopian claim that the
monastery is about to collapse is false.
"The building is very fine, and not dangerous to someone," he said.
The most recent round of the feud began in 1970, when Ethiopian
monks changed the locks while the Copts were at services on the eve
of Easter and moved in.
The Ethiopian Church has six monasteries and 70 monks in the Holy Land,
according to the office of the patriarch. A handful are stationed
at Deir el-Sultan. The main parts of the Holy Sepulcher are divided
between the Catholics, Armenians, and Greek Orthodox.
Three years before the Easter takeover, Israel captured the Old City
from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast War and found itself in charge of
the Holy Sepulcher.
The Copts appealed to an Israeli court, which ruled that the
Ethiopians should not have altered the fragile status quo at the
church but said it was the government's job to decide what to do. The
government decided not to take action, according to Daniel Rossing,
director of the Jerusalem Center for Jewish-Christian Relations and
an expert on the city's fractious religious mosaic.
International politics likely played a role in the decision:
At the time, Israel had warm ties with Ethiopia and was at war
with Egypt. Later that was reversed: Communists came to power in
Ethiopia and cut ties with Israel, and Egypt and Israel signed a
peace agreement. But Israel still did not act, possibly because of
concerns that angering Ethiopia could hamper the emigration of the
country's Jewish community.
Feuds like the one over Deir el-Sultan "don't have a solution, period,"
Rossing said. "The trick, then, is to do the very best job to make
things as livable as possible, within the limitations of never being
able to solve these issues."
Israel's interior minister, Meir Sheetrit, now plans to mediate
the dispute, and the government will help renovate the site as soon
as the sides can agree on a course of action, said spokesman Ilan
Marciano. But with each side entirely rejecting the other's claim to
the monastery, it is unclear if an agreement is possible.
The feud is only one of a bewildering array of rivalries among
churchmen in the Holy Sepulcher, where each group remains on guard
against any encroachment onto their turf. Fights have flared over
issues such as who is allowed to sweep which steps, and Israeli police
occasionally intervene.
The Israeli government has long wanted to build a fire exit in the
church, which regularly fills with thousands of pilgrims and has only
one main door, but the plan is on hold because the sects cannot agree
where the exit will be built. In another example, a ladder placed on
a ledge over the entrance sometime in the 19th century has remained
there ever since because of a dispute over who has the authority to
take it down.