Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Environmentalist Mariam Sukhudyan v. Armenia's Police

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Environmentalist Mariam Sukhudyan v. Armenia's Police

    Environmentalist Mariam Sukhudyan v. Armenia's Police

    Epress.am (http://www.epress.am/FNew.aspx?nid=7543)
    Nov. 1, 2010


    The case involving local environmentalist Mariam Sukhudyan
    vs. Republic of Armenia police took place at Yerevan's Kentron
    (Center) and Nork Marash Administrative Court today.

    Recall that Sukhudyan filed an appeal because Armenia's police,
    specifically Chief of Police Alik Sarsgyan, violated her "presumption
    of innocence." A criminal case was brought against Sukhudyan, who
    spoke up about abuse in a boarding school for children with special
    needs. She was accused of slander and "false betrayal," by stating
    that Nubarashen No. 11 school teacher Levon Avakyan had sexually
    harassed the students.

    Later, the court found Avakyan guilty and sentenced him to two years
    imprisonment.

    Note that in today's court session, the case was discussed in its
    preparatory phase and the court became acquainted with the details of
    the case.

    Speaking to journalists after the session today, Sukhudyan recalled
    that prior to the court issuing a verdict in the Nubarashen case, RA
    Police Chief Alik Sargsyan, appearing on H1 Public TV, called
    Sukhudyan "a criminal." The plaintiff also noted that head of Police
    Department on Public Relations Sayat Shirinyan, speaking about the
    written request by 20 NGOs in Sukhudyan's defense, in a phone
    conversation with a journalist, had said: "This claim is toilet paper,
    she is a criminal, ay, you will come and kneel before the court, you
    will ask us to reduce the charges against the criminal."

    Sukhudyan was angry that her guilt not yet proven, the police chief
    and Shirinyan had made such incriminating statements.

    "But in the preliminary stage, you don't have a right to say that she
    is already a criminal and is accused of slandering or defaming minors;
    that is, he not only violated my presumed innocence, but also guided
    the preliminary investigation; that is a more serious issue, and that
    coming from the police chief. That's why I decided to give a logical
    process to this case. This move is good for them too, because the
    police's immunity has fallen drastically, and this is a good
    opportunity to raise this issue," she said.

    If her case isn't resolved in Armenia, said Sukhudyan, she's preparing
    to take it to the European court.

    In the opinion of Sukhudyan's attorney Liparit Simonyan, the court
    will make a fair decision.

    Note that speaking for the defense, Gayane Gasparyan from the police,
    told journalists:

    "The issue is about journalistic ethics because Sayat Shirinyan had a
    phone conversation with a journalist and was not informed whether [his
    comments] were going to be published or not. Within the framework of
    the case let me say that Sayat Shirinyan did not express an opinion on
    Mariam Sukhudyan's guilt and didn't provide an opinion on the claim
    presented by the NGOs supporting Mariam Sukhudyan."

    The next court session is scheduled for Dec. 15 at 11:30 am.




    From: A. Papazian
Working...
X