Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Other Side of Details

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Other Side of Details

    Kommersant, Russia
    June 30 2005

    Other Side of Details


    // What Russian Ministry Keeps from the UN reports on weapons


    Recently United Nations published on its website official information
    about Russian export of conventional weapons in 2004. The Ministry of
    Foreign Affairs of Russia provided for the document rare details. The
    report shows the volumes of the weapons supplied to the countries,
    which Russian officials usually do not mention and never comment
    upon. However, the experts think that the UN register does not include
    all Russian weapon supplies.


    In December 1991, the UN General Assembly voted for creation of the
    register of conventional weapons, which would be based on the report
    of the all principal sales of weapons around the world. The register
    includes seven main categories of the weapons: armored personnel
    carriers and armored wheeled vehicles; tanks; artillery of big calibers
    and multiple rocket launchers; military planes; military helicopters;
    warships; missile systems. The missile systems include all types of
    guided missiles supplied for army, navy and air force. Each category
    shows the country-receiver of certain weapons and amount of the supply.

    The main reason for the creation of such register was war between Iraq
    and Kuwait and followed operation Desert Storm. The countries submit
    the information into the register on voluntary base. According to
    the General Assembly decision the states have to provide the annual
    data for examination in April of each year. However, these terms
    are not followed religiously. For instance, as of today such large
    weapon exporters as USA, France, Great Britain, Israel, and also one
    of the biggest importers - India, still did not provide the required
    information. China does not submit its data into the register since
    1997.

    In Russia the Foreign Ministry gathers the data for submission, after
    it receives the report from Federal Service of Military-Technical
    Cooperation, Rosoboronexport (the biggest state owned weapon exporter)
    and from the enterprises that have a license to export their own
    production. Compare with other countries, Russia doesn't break
    down what types of weapons were sold but simply put total amount of
    export. Russia also submits to UN the information about its supply to
    the countries, which signed inter-government agreement not to disclose
    the details of military-technical partnerships. For instance, Russia
    has such agreements with China and Vietnam. Thus, despite the fact
    that Russian officials formally announced that "the weapons export
    to China and Vietnam traditionally stays without comments," the
    information about it still becomes public.

    According to the data sent by the foreign ministry for the year 2004,
    the main articles of Russian export in that period were fighter jets.
    For instance, 24 aircraft were shipped to China (Su-30MK2; here and
    further are shown possible types of weapons), 10-to India (Su-30MKI),
    9 in Sudan (8 MiG-29SE and 1 MiG-29UB), 5 in Ethiopia (old Su-27 from
    the current Russian air force), 4 in Vietnam (Su-30NK2B), 2 in Yemen
    (MiG-29SMT) and 2 in Eritrea (MiG-29SE), 1 in Algiers (Su-24MK).
    Besides two ground attack planes Su25 were supplied to Armenia within
    the frame of Organization of Collective Security Agreement (OCSA).
    The helicopter export in 2004 contained four crafts sold to Sudan
    (Mi-24), three in Ethiopia (Mi-17) and one in India (Ka-31). In Naval
    weapons systems, Russia sold one ship to India (Frigate Project 11356)
    and one to China (Submarine Project 636M). In 2004, Yemen received
    128 armored personnel carriers (BMP-2) and Kazakhstan got two within
    the frame of OSCA.

    However, the supplies of Russian missiles systems look much more
    impressive. China received 749 units (guided missiles for jet fighters
    Su-30MK2, missiles for the submarine project 636 and complexes of
    anti-aircraft defense S-300PMU-1, naval anti-aircraft missile complex
    Reef-M and Steel-1). India acquired 122 units (missiles for Su-30MKI,
    attack and anti-aircraft missiles for the Frigate Project 11356),
    Vietnam purchased 20 units to arm four Su-30MK2B.

    However, according to the opinion of independent experts the UN
    register does not reflect full information abut Russian weapons
    export. "There were several cases when Russian suppliers submitted
    to the foreign ministry for the UN registry incomplete information
    about its total deals for the year," Konstantin Makienko, deputy
    director of Center of Analysis of Strategies and Technologies, told
    Kommersant. "For instance, the results of 2003 did not reflect two
    frigates for India and in 2004 one ship Project 12332 for Greece.
    Sometimes the reason for the underreporting is not political, but
    rather bureaucratic miscalculations. There were some cases when the
    suppliers were late with the data and the ministry of foreign affairs
    doesn't have enough competent and informed specialists in the field
    of weapons export."

    by Konstantin Lantratov
Working...
X