Tweet
DARE WE CALL IT GENOCIDEGATE?
Kevin Roderick
LA Observed, CA
April 26 2007
Nah, but the LA Weekly's Daniel Hernandez adds good new details in
the dispute we reported Tuesday between Times managing editor Doug
Frantz and West magazine staff writer Mark Arax. After Frantz killed
a story by Arax claiming that he had a bias conflict as an Armenian
American, Arax emailed some in the newsroom:
Colleagues, You should know that I had a Page One story killed this
week by Doug Frantz. His stated rationale for killing the piece had
nothing to do with any problems with the story itself. In an email
to me, he cited no bias, no factual errors, no contextual mishaps,
no glaring holes....
Because his logic is so illogical, questions must be raised about
Frantz' own objectivity, his past statements to colleagues that he
personally opposes an Armenian genocide resolution and his friendship
with Turkish government officials, including the consul general in
Los Angeles who's quoted in my story. Frantz is heavily involved and
invested in defending the policies of Turkey.
Frantz lived in Istanbul for the Times and the New York Times for
several years just before coming to L.A. in 2005 to be managing editor
for his close friend Dean Baquet. What happens now that the fight is
out in the open, and Baquet is gone, is hard to predict.
Arax's assignment at West is ending - the magazine's staff of
anointed lead writers is being disbanded as part of a downsizing of
West's ambition - and he could have trouble finding a landing spot
within the paper during this era of buyouts and layoffs. There's
also speculation about Frantz. He doesn't seem to have gotten strong
backing in this episode from editor Jim O'Shea, who inherited Baquet's
number two. Then there's the question of why Frantz is moderating a
panel in Istanbul next month that includes a speaker that Armenians
consider a "notorious genocide denialist." The LA Weekly story talks
about previous Armenian community complaints about Frantz.
http://www.laobserved.com/archive/2007/04 /dare_we_call_it_genocide.php
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Kevin Roderick
LA Observed, CA
April 26 2007
Nah, but the LA Weekly's Daniel Hernandez adds good new details in
the dispute we reported Tuesday between Times managing editor Doug
Frantz and West magazine staff writer Mark Arax. After Frantz killed
a story by Arax claiming that he had a bias conflict as an Armenian
American, Arax emailed some in the newsroom:
Colleagues, You should know that I had a Page One story killed this
week by Doug Frantz. His stated rationale for killing the piece had
nothing to do with any problems with the story itself. In an email
to me, he cited no bias, no factual errors, no contextual mishaps,
no glaring holes....
Because his logic is so illogical, questions must be raised about
Frantz' own objectivity, his past statements to colleagues that he
personally opposes an Armenian genocide resolution and his friendship
with Turkish government officials, including the consul general in
Los Angeles who's quoted in my story. Frantz is heavily involved and
invested in defending the policies of Turkey.
Frantz lived in Istanbul for the Times and the New York Times for
several years just before coming to L.A. in 2005 to be managing editor
for his close friend Dean Baquet. What happens now that the fight is
out in the open, and Baquet is gone, is hard to predict.
Arax's assignment at West is ending - the magazine's staff of
anointed lead writers is being disbanded as part of a downsizing of
West's ambition - and he could have trouble finding a landing spot
within the paper during this era of buyouts and layoffs. There's
also speculation about Frantz. He doesn't seem to have gotten strong
backing in this episode from editor Jim O'Shea, who inherited Baquet's
number two. Then there's the question of why Frantz is moderating a
panel in Istanbul next month that includes a speaker that Armenians
consider a "notorious genocide denialist." The LA Weekly story talks
about previous Armenian community complaints about Frantz.
http://www.laobserved.com/archive/2007/04 /dare_we_call_it_genocide.php
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress