Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Majority around the world reject U.S. role of world policeman

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Majority around the world reject U.S. role of world policeman

    Malaysia Sun, Malaysia
    May 19 2007


    Majority around the world reject U.S. role of world policeman

    Malaysia Sun
    Saturday 19th May, 2007



    A multinational poll finds that people around the world reject the
    idea that the United States should play the role of pre-eminent world
    leader.

    Most people say the United States plays the role of world policeman
    more than it should, fails to take their country's interests into
    account and cannot be trusted to act responsibly.

    But the survey also finds that majorities in most countries want the
    United States to participate in international efforts to address
    world problems. Views are divided about whether the United States
    should reduce the number of military bases it has overseas. Moreover,
    many people think their country's relations with the United States
    are improving.

    Americans largely agree with the rest of the world: most do not think
    the United States should remain the world's pre-eminent leader and
    prefer that it play a more cooperative role. They also believe the
    United States plays the role of world policeman more than it should.

    This is the fourth in a series of reports based on a worldwide poll
    about key international issues conducted by The Chicago Council on
    Global Affairs and WorldPublicOpinion.org, in cooperation with
    polling organizations around the world. The larger study includes
    polls in China, India, the United States, Indonesia, Russia, France,
    Thailand, Ukraine, Poland, Iran, Mexico, South Korea, the
    Philippines, Australia, Argentina, Peru, Israel and Armenia - plus
    the Palestinian territories.

    The people polled represent about 56 percent of the world's
    population. Not all questions were asked in all countries.

    Steven Kull, editor of WorldPublicOpinion.org notes the poll
    reinforces the conclusions of other recent global surveys, which have
    found that the United States' image abroad is bad and growing worse.
    But he added that it goes further, exploring what kind of role the
    international community would like the United States to play in the
    world.

    `This survey shows that despite the negative views of US foreign
    policy, people around the world do not want the United States to
    disengage from international affairs, but rather to participate in a
    more cooperative and multilateral fashion,' Kull said.

    Majorities in all 15 of the countries polled about the United States'
    role in the world reject the idea that `as the sole remaining
    superpower, the US should continue to be the pre-eminent world leader
    in solving international problems.' However majorities in only two
    areas (Argentina and the Palestinian territories) say that the United
    States `should withdraw from most efforts to solve international
    problems.' The preferred view in all of the other cases is that the
    United States `should do its share in efforts to solve international
    problems together with other countries.'

    In Asia, large majorities embrace the idea that the United States
    should play a cooperative role in South Korea (79%) and China (68%).
    A majority of Filipinos (55%) and a plurality of Indians (42%) also
    take this view, but they are among the few with substantial numbers
    saying the United States should play the role of the pre-eminent
    world leader: 20 percent in the Philippines and 34 percent in India.
    They are also relatively reluctant to support a co-operative role
    (47%), but very few endorse a pre-eminent role (8%) or disengagement
    (18%), while 27 percent declined to answer.

    In Europe, the French are those most emphatic in their support for a
    co-operative role (75%), followed by Armenia (58%). A majority of
    Ukrainians (52%) also support this position, but an unusually high
    number (34%) supports US disengagement. In Russia, a plurality (42%)
    favors a co-operative role, but this is barely more than the
    percentage (38%) that favors disengagement.

    In Latin America, about six in ten Peruvians (61%) and Mexicans (59%)
    believe the United States should cooperate with other countries to
    solve international problems. However, as mentioned above, Argentines
    are one of only two countries favoring US withdrawal from
    international efforts with 55 percent taking this position and 34
    percent in favor of co-operation.

    In the Middle East, Israelis and Palestinians differ sharply. A
    majority of Palestinians favor US disengagement (55%) while more than
    a third (36%) prefers co-operation. Israelis are more in line with
    most other people in that 62 percent favor US co-operation, but they
    also show the second highest level of support (after India) for the
    US taking the role of pre-eminent leader (24%).

    Americans match the French in their support for the United States
    doing its share together with other nations (75%), with small numbers
    favoring a preeminent role (10%) or isolationism (12%).

    Majorities in 13 out of 15 countries polled say the United States is
    `playing the role of world policeman more than it should be.' This is
    the sentiment of about three-quarters or more of those polled in:
    France (89%), Australia (80%), China (77%), Russia (76%), Peru (76%),
    the Palestinian territories (74%) and South Korea (73%).

    The US public is also among those most convinced that the United
    States too often plays the role of world policeman. Seventy-six
    percent of Americans agree that their country is overdoing such
    activities.

    In only one country does a majority disagree with the idea that the
    United States tends to take on the role of international enforcer
    more than it should: the Philippines. Fifty-seven percent of
    Filipinos reject the idea that the United States plays a police role
    too often, while only a third (31%) agrees that it does.

    Israelis, who are the United States' closest allies in the Middle
    East, are divided over whether the United States plays the global
    policeman role too often. Forty-eight percent of Israelis agree and
    forty-eight percent disagree.

    The five other countries where majorities believe the United States
    is too often acting as world policeman are: Indonesia (68%), Ukraine
    (67%), Armenia (63%), Argentina (62%) and India (53%). In India, a
    country which has been among the most positive about the United
    States in recent years, a third (33%) disagrees.

    The survey also asks respondents in nine countries whether the United
    States has the `responsibility to play the role of `world policeman,'
    that is to fight violations of international law and aggression
    wherever they occur.' Majorities in eight of the nine countries say
    the United States does not have the responsibility to fight
    aggression and enforce international law. The exception is India,
    where a slight majority (53%) says the US does have this
    responsibility while a third (35%) says it does not.

    Palestinians (76%) are the most likely of the people surveyed to
    answer that the United States does not have such a responsibility.
    The next most likely are Americans themselves. Three-quarters of
    Americans (75%) reject the idea that their country has a duty to
    enforce international law.

    Strong majorities of Armenians (70%), Australians (70%), Indonesians
    (69%), and Ukrainians (69%) also agree that the United States does
    not have this responsibility.

    The United States' greatest economic and military rival in
    Asia - China - and one of its closest allies - South Korea - are equally
    likely to reject the idea that the US government has a duty to
    enforce international law. Sixty-one percent of Chinese and60 percent
    of South Koreans answer no. South Koreans are only somewhat more
    likely to say yes (39%) than the Chinese (30%).

    In 10 out of 15 countries, the most common view is that the United
    States cannot be trusted to `act responsibly in the world.'
    Respondents were allowed to choose whether the United States could be
    trusted `a great deal,' `somewhat,' `not very much' or `not at all.'

    Two Latin American countries show the least trust in the United
    States. An overwhelming 84 percent of Argentines answer that they
    have little confidence in the United States, including 69 percent who
    think the United States cannot be trusted at all. Eight in ten
    Peruvians (80%) also think the US cannot be trusted (23% not at all).


    Most Russian and French respondents agree. Nearly three-quarters of
    Russians (73%) express little trust and a third (31%) says the United
    States cannot be trusted at all. The French are almost equally
    skeptical: 72 percent do not trust the United States to behave
    responsibly, including 30 percent who do not trust it at all.

    Also among those who believe the United States generally cannot be
    trusted are: Indonesians (64%), Armenians (59%), Chinese (59%), Thais
    (56%) and South Koreans (53%). Half of Indian respondents (50%) also
    express little or no confidence.

    In four countries, majorities say the United States can be at least
    somewhat trusted to act responsibly. Filipinos (85%) are the most
    willing to trust the United States and half of them think the United
    States can be trusted a great deal (48%). Eight in ten Israelis (81%)
    also believe this. They are also the most willing to say the United
    States can be trusted a great deal (56%). Australians (59%) also tend
    to trust the United States (18% a great deal).

    In two eastern European countries, about half believe the United
    States can be trusted: 51 percent in Poland - though most of these
    (44%) think the United States can only be trusted somewhat - and 49
    percent in Ukraine, 31 percent of whom answer somewhat. About a third
    of Poles (32%) and Ukrainians (37%) say the United States cannot be
    trusted and large numbers are uncertain (17% and 24% respectively).

    US Willingness to Consider Other Interests

    Of the seven countries polled on this question, five believe the
    United States does not take their interests into account when making
    foreign policy decisions. Only in Israel does a large majority
    believe that the United States takes their interest into account.
    Indians are divided. In the other five countries, majorities answer
    `not very much' or `not at all' when asked whether the United States
    takes their interests into account.

    Three former Soviet-bloc countries are the most likely to think that
    the United States fails to consider their concerns. Although Poles
    tend to have fairly positive views of the United States,
    three-quarters (76%) think that the United States does not take their
    interests into account very much (57%) or does not do so at all
    (19%).

    Two-thirds of Russians (66%) also think the United States ignores
    their interests, including a third who think it ignores them entirely
    (33%). Ukrainian feelings are similar: 63 percent say the United
    States tends not to take their interests into account, including 38
    percent who say it does not take them into account at all.

    In Asia, the most common view in two countries (China and Thailand)
    is that their interests are not considered by the United States when
    making foreign policy decisions. A majority of Chinese (58%) believe
    this, of whom 23 percent say the US does not do so at all. A
    plurality of Thais (49%) say the United States does not take their
    interests into account (30% not very much, 19% not at all) compared
    to 23 percent who believe it does (15% somewhat, 8% a great deal).

    However Indians are divided. Forty-six percent say the United States
    does not take their interests into account (23% not at all), while 44
    percent say that it does take their interests into account (24%
    somewhat, 20% a great deal).

    The Israelis stand out as the only country where a strong majority
    (57%) says that the United States takes their interests into account
    a great deal while an additional 25 percent say that it does so
    somewhat. Thus a remarkable total of 82 percent of Israelis say that
    the United States takes their interests into account. A mere 14
    percent disagree.

    US Overseas Military Bases

    Despite the widespread belief that the United States should not be
    the world's pre-eminent leader and that it plays the role of world
    policeman more than it should, countries express mixed views about
    whether the United States should reduce its military presence around
    the world. Nonetheless, very few support increasing the number of
    bases.

    Twelve publics were asked whether the United States should have more,
    fewer or the same number of long-term bases overseas. In six of them,
    including the US public, majorities or pluralities think the United
    States should maintain or increase the number of bases it maintains
    overseas. In five countries, majorities call for reductions. One
    country - India, again - is divided.

    Those most in favor of the United States' at least maintaining its
    overseas military presence are Filipinos, Americans Israelis and
    Poles. Those most likely to support a decreased presence are
    Argentines, Palestinians, the French and the Chinese.

    Filipinos - whose government forced the United States to shut down
    its last base on Philippine territory 15 years ago - are the most
    likely to say that the United States should maintain its long-term
    overseas military presence. Nearly four in five respondents in the
    Philippines (78%) say the United States should either keep `about as
    many' bases as now (60%) or add more bases (18%).

    Sixty-eight percent of Americans think the United States should
    either keep as many bases as now (53%) or add bases (15%). Only 27
    percent say the United States should have fewer bases.

    A majority of Israelis (59%) believe the United States should
    maintain a strong military presence overseas. Of these, 39 percent
    say the United States should keep its current number of bases and 20
    percent say it should have more.

    Respondents in Poland - one of the United States' staunchest allies
    in Europe - also believe the United States should keep as many or
    more military bases overseas as it has today (54%). Most of these
    (45%) believe the United States should maintain the same number of
    bases and 9 percent believe there should be more.

    Pluralities in Armenia and Thailand favor keeping or increasing US
    overseas bases over decreasing them. Armenians are in favor of
    maintaining the US military presence abroad by a margin of 42 percent
    to 37 percent. Thais support it by a margin of 34 percent to 25
    percent, with 41 percent not answering.

    Of the twelve countries polled, Argentines are those most in favor of
    shutting down US bases overseas (75%). Palestinians and the French
    are next with seven in ten (70% and 69% respectively) saying the
    United States should reduce its military presence abroad.

    A majority of Chinese - an emerging military and economic power in
    Asia - also thinks the United States should have fewer bases. Three
    in five (63%) say it should reduce its overseas presence.

    A majority of Ukrainians (62%) think that the United States should
    have fewer bases while 13 percent say it should keep the current
    number. Only 3 percent think it needs more and 22 percent are unsure.

    Indians are evenly divided between those who say the United States
    should increase or maintain its bases overseas and those who believe
    it should decrease them. Thirty nine percent believe the US needs
    more (26%) or the same number (13%) and 39 percent say it should have
    fewer. About a fifth of Indian respondents (22%) are unsure.

    Also contrary to the largely negative views of the United States'
    role in the world is the perception in some countries - including some
    that are highly critical of the United States - that bilateral
    relations with the United State States are improving. Eleven
    countries were asked whether relations of their country with the
    United States were `improving, worsening, or staying about the same.'


    Six of the eleven countries say their relations with the United
    States show signs of improvement, including majorities in India (58%)
    and China (53%) and pluralities in Australia (50%), Armenia (48%),
    Indonesia (46%) and Thailand (37%).

    In the remaining five countries, majorities or pluralities say
    relations with the United States are staying about the same: 60
    percent in Poland, 56 percent in South Korea, 52 percent in Israel,
    52 percent in the Ukraine, and 45 percent in Russia.

    In no country, does even a plurality think relations are getting
    worse. South Korea has the largest minority saying that relations
    with the United States are worsening (34%), followed by Thailand
    (28%) and Indonesia (23%). Among the other eight countries, only 8
    percent to 20 percent feel this way.

    `The publics in many countries differentiate between their negative
    views of the US international role and their perceptions of bilateral
    relations, which are seen as improving in a significant number of
    countries, even some that are highly critical of the United States,'
    said Christopher Whitney, executive director for studies at The
    Chicago Council on Global Affairs.
Working...
X