Tweet
THE REPUBLICAN DEBATE: FIRST TAKE
Atlantic Online
http://marcambinder.theatlantic.com/archive s/2007/10/the_republican_debate_first_ta.php
Oct 22 2007
As the Republicans debated who is more conservative tonight, two
voices stood out: Mitt Romney's and Rudy Giuliani's.
At long last, Romney defended and touted and bragged about the singular
political and policy accomplishment of his tenure as Massachusetts
governor: the health care system reform that provides every resident
there with insurance. Watching him at other debates, it was easy to
get the sense that he wasn't sure how to integrate his Massachusetts
experience into his campaign narrative. The plan itself was written
with the help of Heritage Foundation experts but it did not, in the
end, comport with every conservative principle.
But it stands out as an prime example -- perhaps the ultimate example
-- of conservative governance. Romney worked hard at health care in
Massachusetts; he worked with Democrats; he worked with Republicans;
he wound up with a novel program that, while not perfect and not
transferable to other states, stands out as a real accomplishment.
Romney calls himself an executive and a manager; with health care,
he executed and managed in real time. At their Michigan debate,
Republicans seemed a bit reality-deaf and barely acknowledged the sense
of economic dislocation that middle class Republicans feel; Tonight,
Romney demonstrated that, given the right scenario, he can connect
with those voters better than just about any candidate up there.
His best moment may have been when he said that an insurmountable
problem like the health care crisis can, indeed, be solved. It wasn't
just a candidate saying he was optimistic; he showed how optimism,
will and plod can be potent problem-solving forces.
After a tentative start, Giuliani again proved that he is so adept in
these formats and can handle really any question with finesse. And
he showed, again, that he is the Republican who best frames the
race against Hillary Clinton. He's a natural at it. Also: Giuliani
should get some props from Ezra Klein: he accurately pointed out that
Medicare is in much worse shape than Social Security and is a much
more serious problem. At the end of the debate, he gave an answer on
Iran that sounded reasonable and not Podhoretz-esque.
Fred Thompson started off better than he finished -- a meandering
answer on Turkey did not come off very well. At one point, he seemed
not to recognize that the Armenian Genocide proposal is already,
well, dead. He did have a cute final answer on his laziness.
John McCain -- the only standing ovation belonged to him for his
classic line about Hillary Clinton's Woodstock museum earmark: "I'm
sure it was an historical and pharmaceutical event... I was tied up
at the time." He tried hard -- at times too hard -- to rise above
his opponents, talking just a little too slowly and softly at times.
Substantively, he was crisp and detailed.
Ron Paul -- what to say about a man who draws more boos than Hillary
Clinton from the crowd?
Mike Huckabee -- Last debate, he faded into the background while
Thompson came into relief; this time, Huckabee stood his own, but
didn't have any breakout moments.
Atlantic Online
http://marcambinder.theatlantic.com/archive s/2007/10/the_republican_debate_first_ta.php
Oct 22 2007
As the Republicans debated who is more conservative tonight, two
voices stood out: Mitt Romney's and Rudy Giuliani's.
At long last, Romney defended and touted and bragged about the singular
political and policy accomplishment of his tenure as Massachusetts
governor: the health care system reform that provides every resident
there with insurance. Watching him at other debates, it was easy to
get the sense that he wasn't sure how to integrate his Massachusetts
experience into his campaign narrative. The plan itself was written
with the help of Heritage Foundation experts but it did not, in the
end, comport with every conservative principle.
But it stands out as an prime example -- perhaps the ultimate example
-- of conservative governance. Romney worked hard at health care in
Massachusetts; he worked with Democrats; he worked with Republicans;
he wound up with a novel program that, while not perfect and not
transferable to other states, stands out as a real accomplishment.
Romney calls himself an executive and a manager; with health care,
he executed and managed in real time. At their Michigan debate,
Republicans seemed a bit reality-deaf and barely acknowledged the sense
of economic dislocation that middle class Republicans feel; Tonight,
Romney demonstrated that, given the right scenario, he can connect
with those voters better than just about any candidate up there.
His best moment may have been when he said that an insurmountable
problem like the health care crisis can, indeed, be solved. It wasn't
just a candidate saying he was optimistic; he showed how optimism,
will and plod can be potent problem-solving forces.
After a tentative start, Giuliani again proved that he is so adept in
these formats and can handle really any question with finesse. And
he showed, again, that he is the Republican who best frames the
race against Hillary Clinton. He's a natural at it. Also: Giuliani
should get some props from Ezra Klein: he accurately pointed out that
Medicare is in much worse shape than Social Security and is a much
more serious problem. At the end of the debate, he gave an answer on
Iran that sounded reasonable and not Podhoretz-esque.
Fred Thompson started off better than he finished -- a meandering
answer on Turkey did not come off very well. At one point, he seemed
not to recognize that the Armenian Genocide proposal is already,
well, dead. He did have a cute final answer on his laziness.
John McCain -- the only standing ovation belonged to him for his
classic line about Hillary Clinton's Woodstock museum earmark: "I'm
sure it was an historical and pharmaceutical event... I was tied up
at the time." He tried hard -- at times too hard -- to rise above
his opponents, talking just a little too slowly and softly at times.
Substantively, he was crisp and detailed.
Ron Paul -- what to say about a man who draws more boos than Hillary
Clinton from the crowd?
Mike Huckabee -- Last debate, he faded into the background while
Thompson came into relief; this time, Huckabee stood his own, but
didn't have any breakout moments.