Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Mr. Joseph Berman Unqualified for Superior Court

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Mr. Joseph Berman Unqualified for Superior Court

    Mr. Joseph Berman Unqualified for Superior Court

    Joseph Dagdigian, Harvard, MA, 28 February 2014


    As suburban Boston constituencies look on, Governor Deval Patrick is
    still insisting that the eight elected Governor's Councilors accept
    his nominee, attorney Joseph Berman, to be a Superior Court judge..

    After Mr. Berman's first hearing on Nov 13, 2013, a majority of
    Councilors indicated that they would not vote in favor of Patrick's
    desired candidate.

    Many of their reasons stem from issues of character. They included
    Mr. Berman's not being honest during sworn testimony when asked about
    his having elected officials lobby the Councilors on his behalf; his
    hefty campaign contributions to Democratic candidates since being
    turned down for a judgeship in 2004; his sarcastic attitude when
    questioned by Councilors; his lack of criminal trial experience; his
    lack of knowledge about and/or dismissive demeanor when asked about
    drug addiction issues; and his controversial decision to not resign
    from the Anti-Defamation League- an organization which hypocritically
    works against Congressional recognition of the Armenian Genocide.

    Once it was known that Mr. Berman was not supported by the majority,
    Governor Patrick postponed a vote and, instead, intensely politicked
    to urge Councilors to reverse their position. This culminated in Gov.
    Patrick's withdrawing the Berman nomination, only to resubmit it, and
    call for a second hearing for Mr. Berman, which was just held on Feb.
    26, 2014.

    As an attendee at that hearing, it appeared to me that Councilors were
    bending to political pressure. I conclude this because when their
    formerly stated reasons for opposing his nomination were inadequately
    readdressed on the floor, some Councilors surprisingly indicated that
    they now found acceptable what they at first did not. Now, Mr. Berman
    indicated he did not fully understand the questions previously asked
    about his lobbying efforts. Now, campaign contributions suddenly
    appeared reasonable, given that he, too, was a Democrat supporting his
    chosen political party members. Now, he was simply misunderstood when
    he had offered curt replies to questions. Now, since the first
    hearing, he's qualified since he read a book about drug addiction and
    gone to a drug court. Now, some Councilors felt that Mr. Berman should
    not be penalized for his shameful failure, as a National Commissioner
    of the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), to take a moral stance against
    the ADL's siding with Turkey and lobbying to squash Armenian Genocide
    recognition resolutions in Congress. Genocide is an international
    crime, and the US is a signatory to the Convention on the Prevention
    and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

    To what do we owe this sudden tolerance and acceptance? How is it that
    some Councilors now seem willing to overlook Mr. Berman's character
    and professional deficits?

    During the hearing's recess, Mr. Berman was seen outside the meeting
    hall "high-fiving" some of his colleagues, signaling his perception of
    an imminent victory. Is this the sort of sober comportment we want in
    a judge?

    It appears as if Governor Patrick is helping Mr. Berman pursue a
    position for which he is ill-qualified to hold. Massachusetts
    citizens deserve a mature, reasoned and unbiased judge on the bench.
    Mr. Berman does not merit that distinction.

    READER COMMENT:
    A vote may take place as soon as this Wednesday, March 5.
    To express your concerns to the Governor's Councilors, you may send
    your emails to:
    Ms. Marilyn Devaney = [email protected]
    Mr. Robert Jubinville = [email protected]
    Ms. Jennie Caissie = [email protected]
    Mr. Oliver Cipollini = [email protected]

    http://www.keghart.com/Dagdigian-Berman

Working...
X