Tweet
Hurriyet Daily News, Turkey
May 10 2014
Growing pains in Turkey
by GÃ`VEN SAK
Turkey is a country in flux. My personal history happens to cover all
the major parts of my country's transformation. I was born in the
western part of Turkey in 1961. The first industrial zone of the
country was also established in that same in year in Bursa, my
hometown. Industrialization started with industrial zones and Bursa
was one of the leading cities outside of Istanbul and Ä°zmir. At the
time, Ankara was a city of civil servants only. Only a year had passed
since the city had seen its first coup d'etat. Turkey was just a
sleepy agrarian country.
In the years after my birth, private sector-based industrialization
started to sprawl across Anatolia. The army really got into the swing
of coup d'etats. So I consider myself as having seen it all. I may be
wrong, but that is my feeling nowadays as I follow one anti-democratic
measure after another from the government. The rule of law has always
been problematic in Turkey, but this seems to be a period where we
have more at stake, as today's Turkey is more developed and richer. We
have more to lose than ever before. When I was born, we only had `our
chains to lose,' so to speak. I do not just want to underline our
historically high current account deficits that need to be financed at
all costs. This time it is definitely different.
When my friends outside the country ask me what is happening in Turkey
nowadays, I still tend to tell them that it is all growing pains. I
consider today's events as a continuation of the past. In Turkey, it
may not feel like something as normal as getting more mature over
time, but that is what it is. When you are the one experiencing it,
the process feels horrible with no end in sight. I still remember the
years of the 1980 coup. It was like living in a horror movie,
especially if you were a university student at the time, like I was.
Despite all the costs, so much has changed for the good in the last
five decades. It is definitely like the opening chapter of Charles
Dickens' `A Tale of Two Cities.' It is the best of times, it is the
worst of times, it is the age of wisdom, it is the age of foolishness,
it is the epoch of belief, it is the epoch of incredulity, it is the
season of light, it is the season of darkness, it is the spring of
hope, it is the winter of despair. Just look at recent developments.
Today, it is once again the best of times. The prime minister has
offered his condolences over the loss of lives over the 1915 Armenian
massacres. You may discuss the nuances, you may not like the tone of
his voice; none of it changes the fact that a Turkish prime minister
talked about `our shared pain' for the first time. Now, add this to
the football diplomacy process of Turkish President Abdullah Gül and
Turkish President Serzh Sargsyan. All of them are steps in the right
direction. Gül and Sargsyan's diplomacy was the first crack in the
wall. Now that same crack is becoming wider and wider. So far, so
good. Does that mean that Turkey has finally come to terms with its
long and proud history? Not yet.
Does that mean that Turkey is finally at peace with its own geography?
Not yet. But we are one step closer. That means that it is possible
for a growing number of civil institutions to focus on the issue. Now
that talking about the issue no longer requires heroes, it is time for
ordinary citizens to take part in the discussion. Without a doubt,
Prime Minister ErdoÄ?an's remark has truly democratized the discussion
on Ottoman Armenians.
I bear in mind that this is also still the worst of times, but today
let me focus on only the good side.
May/10/2014
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/growing-pains-in-turkey.aspx?pageID=449&nID=66255&NewsCatID=403
From: A. Papazian
May 10 2014
Growing pains in Turkey
by GÃ`VEN SAK
Turkey is a country in flux. My personal history happens to cover all
the major parts of my country's transformation. I was born in the
western part of Turkey in 1961. The first industrial zone of the
country was also established in that same in year in Bursa, my
hometown. Industrialization started with industrial zones and Bursa
was one of the leading cities outside of Istanbul and Ä°zmir. At the
time, Ankara was a city of civil servants only. Only a year had passed
since the city had seen its first coup d'etat. Turkey was just a
sleepy agrarian country.
In the years after my birth, private sector-based industrialization
started to sprawl across Anatolia. The army really got into the swing
of coup d'etats. So I consider myself as having seen it all. I may be
wrong, but that is my feeling nowadays as I follow one anti-democratic
measure after another from the government. The rule of law has always
been problematic in Turkey, but this seems to be a period where we
have more at stake, as today's Turkey is more developed and richer. We
have more to lose than ever before. When I was born, we only had `our
chains to lose,' so to speak. I do not just want to underline our
historically high current account deficits that need to be financed at
all costs. This time it is definitely different.
When my friends outside the country ask me what is happening in Turkey
nowadays, I still tend to tell them that it is all growing pains. I
consider today's events as a continuation of the past. In Turkey, it
may not feel like something as normal as getting more mature over
time, but that is what it is. When you are the one experiencing it,
the process feels horrible with no end in sight. I still remember the
years of the 1980 coup. It was like living in a horror movie,
especially if you were a university student at the time, like I was.
Despite all the costs, so much has changed for the good in the last
five decades. It is definitely like the opening chapter of Charles
Dickens' `A Tale of Two Cities.' It is the best of times, it is the
worst of times, it is the age of wisdom, it is the age of foolishness,
it is the epoch of belief, it is the epoch of incredulity, it is the
season of light, it is the season of darkness, it is the spring of
hope, it is the winter of despair. Just look at recent developments.
Today, it is once again the best of times. The prime minister has
offered his condolences over the loss of lives over the 1915 Armenian
massacres. You may discuss the nuances, you may not like the tone of
his voice; none of it changes the fact that a Turkish prime minister
talked about `our shared pain' for the first time. Now, add this to
the football diplomacy process of Turkish President Abdullah Gül and
Turkish President Serzh Sargsyan. All of them are steps in the right
direction. Gül and Sargsyan's diplomacy was the first crack in the
wall. Now that same crack is becoming wider and wider. So far, so
good. Does that mean that Turkey has finally come to terms with its
long and proud history? Not yet.
Does that mean that Turkey is finally at peace with its own geography?
Not yet. But we are one step closer. That means that it is possible
for a growing number of civil institutions to focus on the issue. Now
that talking about the issue no longer requires heroes, it is time for
ordinary citizens to take part in the discussion. Without a doubt,
Prime Minister ErdoÄ?an's remark has truly democratized the discussion
on Ottoman Armenians.
I bear in mind that this is also still the worst of times, but today
let me focus on only the good side.
May/10/2014
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/growing-pains-in-turkey.aspx?pageID=449&nID=66255&NewsCatID=403
From: A. Papazian