Tweet
OPINION: EU AND TURKEY TAKE HISTORIC STEP
Deutsche Welle, Germany
Oct 4 2005
Turkey's boat has finally come in
The EU's wrangling over the negotiation framework with Turkey over
accession has finally reached a happy conclusion. DW's Baha Gungor
heaves a big sigh of relief.
Monday was to have marked the official launch of landmark entry talks
with Turkey. But as the day approached, it seemed more and more
unlikely that the negotiations would go ahead as scheduled. Chief
among the trouble-makers was Austria, which insisted that talks with
Turkey could only begin if accession negotiations were also opened
with Croatia.
But then, contrary to all expectations, a last-ditch deal was reached
after two days of tense debate -- salvaging, just in the nick of time,
the EU's reputation as a sturdy super-structure able to take the heat.
Strategic decision
The long-awaited start of Turkey's entry talks represents an historic
step for the EU, and a key reinforcement of its security interests in
a strategic region. While Turkey once guarded Europe's south-eastern
border as a member of NATO during the Cold War era, it now occupies
a key position within the Middle East conflict belt.
The ultimate aim of the talks is, inevitably, Turkish accession,
but entry is by no means in the bag. It will be years before the
decision is taken whether or not to allow a politically, economically
and socially transformed Turkey to join the EU as a full member. For
the time being, piling on the pressure is counterproductive -- all
it will do is fan the flames of anti-EU sentiment within this mainly
Muslim country.
And the Turkish population's reservations about too hasty a move
towards the EU are just as understandable as Europe's wariness of
Turkey. The country is well aware it still has many obstacles to
weather, and it will be years before its vast regional disparities
can start to narrow. It's a problem Europe has experienced itself
-- and nowhere more painfully than Germany, a country that has been
trying to breach the gap between east and west for the last 15 years,
and paying a heavy cost in the process.
EU compatibility
But Turkey will also have to prove it is EU-compatible when it comes
to democracy, human rights, the Armenian question and the Kurdish
conflict -- which will include demonstrating belief in European values
in its approach to problem-solving.
Sorting out Cyprus is another challenge Turkey faces, and will be a
key test of its willingness to compromise.
Turkey will have to adopt 35 chapters of EU law, and that means every
single EU member state has 35 veto opportunities, since every chapter
has to be unanimously agreed.
Austria's shenanigans over the last few days are more than likely to
be repeated by one country or another, sooner or later. The risk of
failure is acute given that every member state will have to ratify
Turkey's entry agreement, some of which by referendum.
After its speedy intake of eight new eastern European countries last
year, which it's still belly-aching about, the EU now has another
set of problems to deal with. At least it realized in time that it
wouldn't have been fair to vent its frustration on Turkey.
Baha Gungor (jp)
Send Print
Turkey and EU Agree on Membership Talks The European Union clinched
an 11th-hour accord with Turkey Monday to clear the way for landmark
talks with the vast mainly Muslim state to go ahead, after marathon
talks overcame Austrian objections. (Oct. 3, 2005) Turkey Brings EU
to "Edge of Precipice" With Turkey raising new obstacles and Austria
holding out against an accord to clear the way for talks with Ankara,
the European Union teetered on the brink of crisis Monday, and Turkey's
EU hopes hung in the balance. (Oct. 3, 2005) Turkey Challenges EU
to Be "World Player" Turkey's prime minister challenged the European
Union on Sunday to be a "world player" rather than a "Christian club,"
as the bloc deliberated whether to open formal membership talks with
the largely Muslim country. (Oct. 2, 2005)
http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,1564,1729225,00.html
Deutsche Welle, Germany
Oct 4 2005
Turkey's boat has finally come in
The EU's wrangling over the negotiation framework with Turkey over
accession has finally reached a happy conclusion. DW's Baha Gungor
heaves a big sigh of relief.
Monday was to have marked the official launch of landmark entry talks
with Turkey. But as the day approached, it seemed more and more
unlikely that the negotiations would go ahead as scheduled. Chief
among the trouble-makers was Austria, which insisted that talks with
Turkey could only begin if accession negotiations were also opened
with Croatia.
But then, contrary to all expectations, a last-ditch deal was reached
after two days of tense debate -- salvaging, just in the nick of time,
the EU's reputation as a sturdy super-structure able to take the heat.
Strategic decision
The long-awaited start of Turkey's entry talks represents an historic
step for the EU, and a key reinforcement of its security interests in
a strategic region. While Turkey once guarded Europe's south-eastern
border as a member of NATO during the Cold War era, it now occupies
a key position within the Middle East conflict belt.
The ultimate aim of the talks is, inevitably, Turkish accession,
but entry is by no means in the bag. It will be years before the
decision is taken whether or not to allow a politically, economically
and socially transformed Turkey to join the EU as a full member. For
the time being, piling on the pressure is counterproductive -- all
it will do is fan the flames of anti-EU sentiment within this mainly
Muslim country.
And the Turkish population's reservations about too hasty a move
towards the EU are just as understandable as Europe's wariness of
Turkey. The country is well aware it still has many obstacles to
weather, and it will be years before its vast regional disparities
can start to narrow. It's a problem Europe has experienced itself
-- and nowhere more painfully than Germany, a country that has been
trying to breach the gap between east and west for the last 15 years,
and paying a heavy cost in the process.
EU compatibility
But Turkey will also have to prove it is EU-compatible when it comes
to democracy, human rights, the Armenian question and the Kurdish
conflict -- which will include demonstrating belief in European values
in its approach to problem-solving.
Sorting out Cyprus is another challenge Turkey faces, and will be a
key test of its willingness to compromise.
Turkey will have to adopt 35 chapters of EU law, and that means every
single EU member state has 35 veto opportunities, since every chapter
has to be unanimously agreed.
Austria's shenanigans over the last few days are more than likely to
be repeated by one country or another, sooner or later. The risk of
failure is acute given that every member state will have to ratify
Turkey's entry agreement, some of which by referendum.
After its speedy intake of eight new eastern European countries last
year, which it's still belly-aching about, the EU now has another
set of problems to deal with. At least it realized in time that it
wouldn't have been fair to vent its frustration on Turkey.
Baha Gungor (jp)
Send Print
Turkey and EU Agree on Membership Talks The European Union clinched
an 11th-hour accord with Turkey Monday to clear the way for landmark
talks with the vast mainly Muslim state to go ahead, after marathon
talks overcame Austrian objections. (Oct. 3, 2005) Turkey Brings EU
to "Edge of Precipice" With Turkey raising new obstacles and Austria
holding out against an accord to clear the way for talks with Ankara,
the European Union teetered on the brink of crisis Monday, and Turkey's
EU hopes hung in the balance. (Oct. 3, 2005) Turkey Challenges EU
to Be "World Player" Turkey's prime minister challenged the European
Union on Sunday to be a "world player" rather than a "Christian club,"
as the bloc deliberated whether to open formal membership talks with
the largely Muslim country. (Oct. 2, 2005)
http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,1564,1729225,00.html