Tweet
Why is the West pushing for Kosovo's independence?
18:32 | 13/ 12/ 2007
MOSCOW. (RIA Novosti political commentator Ivan Zakharchenko) - The EU
leaders will meet in Brussels on December 14 to demand recognition for
the self-proclaimed independence of Kosovo, a 90% Albanian province in
the south of former Yugoslavia.
The proposed ruling runs contrary to the UN Security Council's
resolution confirming the borders of Serbia, the legal successor of
Yugoslavia, and to Serbian and Russian protests. Moreover, there is no
unity on the issue among the 27 countries of the European Union.
Worse still, the EU's support for Kosovo's independence might encourage
separatist sentiments in other countries, including in some EU
countries.
Why is the EU, supported by the United States, taking this formidable
risk then?
The situation in Kosovo is almost as dramatic as in the Middle East.
The five-month talks to find a scenario that will suit all parties and
Russia's diplomatic efforts to keep the dialogue going have failed.
More than 100,000 Kosovo Serbs are seriously concerned over their
future and Serbia will most likely act in their defense.
Catalonians and Basques in Spain and France, Albanians in Macedonia,
the Irish and Scots in Britain, and separatists in other countries are
closely watching Kosovo's attempts to gain independence.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov told his European colleagues in
Brussels early this week that Kosovo's secession would violate
international law and provoke a chain reaction of secessions in other
regions.
But the EU has closed its eyes to all of the above in its desire to
help the Kosovars.
Viktor Mironenko, head of the EU and Eastern Europe Center at the
Moscow-based Institute of Europe, sees this as an attempt to save face,
because the West has supported everything that has taken place in
Kosovo and is partly to blame for the current situation.
"The West can get out of this deadlock only if a semblance of stability
is maintained in the province, which offers a very short list of
options," Mironenko said.
Mironenko believes that the Albanian-Serb dialogue can continue
forever, and new conflicts can flare up between them any day. Europe
possibly hopes to avoid this by recognizing Kosovo's independence.
Russia, which has decided to firmly back the Serbs, cannot do anything
in this situation, he said.
Vladimir Gutnik, head of European studies at Moscow's Institute of
World Economy and International Relations (IMEMO), said another reason
for the Western readiness to recognize Kosovo's independence is that
the Serbs, unlike the Albanians, have never played by the EU rules.
"It would be strategically better for the EU to have subordinated
Albania and Kosovo and a weakened Serbia," Gutnik said.
In short, the West sees no viable option other than recognizing
Kosovo's independence, even if under the EU supervision. It wants to
turn the tide now and see what happens next.
Cyprus is the only EU country that is against Kosovo's independence,
which makes sense since it has been divided into the Greek and Turkish
parts since 1974. The recognition of Kosovo's independence might give
unnecessary ideas to Turkish Cypriots, whose self-proclaimed republic
has been recognized only by Turkey.
Greece and several other European countries are not in a hurry to
recognize Kosovo's independence, saying that a compromise between
Albanians and Serbs is possible with the mediation of Russia, the
United States and the EU.
Kosovars have already started talks with EU countries to recognize
their independence in early 2008. But Kosovo as an independent state is
unlikely to become a UN member soon, because Russia is likely to use
its veto right.
The main task for the EU will be to ensure safety in Kosovo, in
particular for the remaining Serbs, and prevent new bloodshed. The West
admits that sporadic violence is possible in the province, and plans to
maintain law and order with the help of 16,000 NATO troops deployed in
Kosovo and 1,800 EU policemen to be dispatched there.
Independent Kosovo will need major financial injections to revive its
economy. So far, nobody can determine how much it will need and for how
long, although everyone agrees that stability cannot be restored in
Kosovo without an economic resurgence.
Kosovo's independence can provoke a major crisis, if not a new Balkan
war. To save face, Europe will have to do its utmost to untie the
Kosovo knot, even if Kosovo's independence is officially recognized.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not
necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti.
18:32 | 13/ 12/ 2007
MOSCOW. (RIA Novosti political commentator Ivan Zakharchenko) - The EU
leaders will meet in Brussels on December 14 to demand recognition for
the self-proclaimed independence of Kosovo, a 90% Albanian province in
the south of former Yugoslavia.
The proposed ruling runs contrary to the UN Security Council's
resolution confirming the borders of Serbia, the legal successor of
Yugoslavia, and to Serbian and Russian protests. Moreover, there is no
unity on the issue among the 27 countries of the European Union.
Worse still, the EU's support for Kosovo's independence might encourage
separatist sentiments in other countries, including in some EU
countries.
Why is the EU, supported by the United States, taking this formidable
risk then?
The situation in Kosovo is almost as dramatic as in the Middle East.
The five-month talks to find a scenario that will suit all parties and
Russia's diplomatic efforts to keep the dialogue going have failed.
More than 100,000 Kosovo Serbs are seriously concerned over their
future and Serbia will most likely act in their defense.
Catalonians and Basques in Spain and France, Albanians in Macedonia,
the Irish and Scots in Britain, and separatists in other countries are
closely watching Kosovo's attempts to gain independence.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov told his European colleagues in
Brussels early this week that Kosovo's secession would violate
international law and provoke a chain reaction of secessions in other
regions.
But the EU has closed its eyes to all of the above in its desire to
help the Kosovars.
Viktor Mironenko, head of the EU and Eastern Europe Center at the
Moscow-based Institute of Europe, sees this as an attempt to save face,
because the West has supported everything that has taken place in
Kosovo and is partly to blame for the current situation.
"The West can get out of this deadlock only if a semblance of stability
is maintained in the province, which offers a very short list of
options," Mironenko said.
Mironenko believes that the Albanian-Serb dialogue can continue
forever, and new conflicts can flare up between them any day. Europe
possibly hopes to avoid this by recognizing Kosovo's independence.
Russia, which has decided to firmly back the Serbs, cannot do anything
in this situation, he said.
Vladimir Gutnik, head of European studies at Moscow's Institute of
World Economy and International Relations (IMEMO), said another reason
for the Western readiness to recognize Kosovo's independence is that
the Serbs, unlike the Albanians, have never played by the EU rules.
"It would be strategically better for the EU to have subordinated
Albania and Kosovo and a weakened Serbia," Gutnik said.
In short, the West sees no viable option other than recognizing
Kosovo's independence, even if under the EU supervision. It wants to
turn the tide now and see what happens next.
Cyprus is the only EU country that is against Kosovo's independence,
which makes sense since it has been divided into the Greek and Turkish
parts since 1974. The recognition of Kosovo's independence might give
unnecessary ideas to Turkish Cypriots, whose self-proclaimed republic
has been recognized only by Turkey.
Greece and several other European countries are not in a hurry to
recognize Kosovo's independence, saying that a compromise between
Albanians and Serbs is possible with the mediation of Russia, the
United States and the EU.
Kosovars have already started talks with EU countries to recognize
their independence in early 2008. But Kosovo as an independent state is
unlikely to become a UN member soon, because Russia is likely to use
its veto right.
The main task for the EU will be to ensure safety in Kosovo, in
particular for the remaining Serbs, and prevent new bloodshed. The West
admits that sporadic violence is possible in the province, and plans to
maintain law and order with the help of 16,000 NATO troops deployed in
Kosovo and 1,800 EU policemen to be dispatched there.
Independent Kosovo will need major financial injections to revive its
economy. So far, nobody can determine how much it will need and for how
long, although everyone agrees that stability cannot be restored in
Kosovo without an economic resurgence.
Kosovo's independence can provoke a major crisis, if not a new Balkan
war. To save face, Europe will have to do its utmost to untie the
Kosovo knot, even if Kosovo's independence is officially recognized.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not
necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti.