Tweet
Inside Story: Caught between an Armenian anvil and Turkish hammer
Calev Ben-David , THE JERUSALEM POST Oct. 14, 2007
Abe Foxman must be feeling a little vindication these days - although
that may be of little solace to the outspoken Anti-Defamation League
national director.
Last August, when the ADL's New England chapter defied the
organization's long-standing policy not to formally condemn the
killings of Armenians by Turkish forces during World War I as a
"genocide," Foxman promptly fired regional director Andrew Tarsey.
But under pressure from other local ADL leaders, Armenian activists
and Massachusetts political figures, Foxman reversed his position,
rehiring Tarsey and calling Turkish acts during the war "tantamount to
genocide."
Still, he refused to offer support for a congressional resolution
making the same declaration. "I believe the issue should not be
debated at the US Congress. US congressmen are not historians.
Therefore, they cannot judge what happened in history," Foxman
commented last month, after meeting in New York City with Turkish
Prime Minister Recip Tayipp Erdogan.
The US Congress thought differently, with the House Foreign Affairs
Committee passing a controversial resolution last week labeling the
Turkish actions as genocide.
The political fallout has been swift and harsh, with Turkey condemning
the resolution and recalling its ambassador from Washington.
With rumblings from Ankara about curtailing cooperation with American
forces fighting in Iraq, and even threats of a large cross-border
operation against Kurdish nationalist strongholds in northern Iraq,
this situation is primarily a problem - a big one - for the US.
But it's also one, albeit to a lesser degree, for Israel and the
American Jewish leadership.
Placing a higher priority on its valuable strategic relationship with
Ankara, Jerusalem has resolutely steered clear of the "Armenian
genocide" controversy, as have traditionally, for the most part,
American-Jewish organizations such as the ADL.
"We fully understand the importance of Israel's strategic alliance
with Turkey," said one prominent US Jewish leader, "so over the years,
despite the stand on the issue taken by such individuals as Elie
Wiesel [who has publicly condemned the Turkish actions] we've given
precedence to our concerns about the security of Israel over any
feelings over the need take a moral stand on the Armenian genocide.
"Foxman was right about the substance of the issue last summer," the
leader added, "but he let the situation in Boston get away from him,
and felt he had no choice but to backtrack and accept their position."
That turnaround angered the Turks, who not only blamed the ADL for
reversing its position, but also held Jerusalem in part accountable.
Turkish Foreign Minister Ali Babacan made this clear on visit to
Israel last week, telling The Jerusalem Post, "All of a sudden the
perception in Turkey right now is that the Jewish people - or the
Jewish organizations, let's say, and the Armenian diaspora, the
Armenian lobbies, are now hand-in-hand trying to defame Turkey, and
trying to condemn Turkey and the Turkish people. This is the
unfortunate perception right now in Turkey. So if something goes wrong
in Washington, DC, it inevitably will have some influence on relations
between Turkey and the US, plus the relations between Turkey and
Israel, as well."
Unfortunately, despite the Turkish perception, Armenian activists and
their political supporters in the US were in fact not satisfied with
the change in the ADL's position, especially the continued
unwillingness of Foxman to support the congressional resolution. In
response, three towns outside Boston - Newton, Belmont and Watertown -
under pressure from those activists announced last month that they
were dropping their cooperation with the ADL's "No Place For Hate"
anti-bias program for local municipalities.
"This was really an issue of conscience," Newton Mayor Andrew Cohen
told The Boston Globe. "We certainly hope the national ADL do the
right thing."
He's liable to be disappointed. The ADL's National Commission, its
highest policy-making body, is scheduled to meet during the first week
of November to discuss the issue. According to sources in the
organization, it is likely to support Foxman's position in not backing
the resolution.
That will probably do little, though, to mollify either the Turks or
the Armenians, both of whom seem unwilling to accept any rhetorical
compromise from Jewish leaders.
Nor is this issue likely to go away. American-Armenian activists will
continue to press for wider acceptance of the genocide designation, in
large part using as their model the success of the Jewish community in
raising awareness of the Holocaust. Plans are even being laid to open
a Museum of the Armenian Genocide in Washington, modeled on the US
Holocaust Memorial Museum.
Israel's strategic relationship with Turkey is probably of great
enough value to both nations to not be immediately affected in any
significant way by this controversy. But the long-term impact of this
open wound is far from negligible.
An editorial run this week in Turkey's Today's Zaman newspaper quotes
Babacan as saying, "We have told them [the ADL and other Jewish
groups] that we cannot explain it to the Turkish public if a road
accident happens. We have told them that we cannot keep the Jewish
people out of this."
The editorial goes on: "Babacan is right. In the event of the adoption
of the Armenian genocide resolution at the Congress, there will be a
costly bill awaiting all parties."
According to an unscientific readers poll in Today's Zaman over the
weekend, when presented with a series of choices regarding which
factor is primarily responsible for the proposed congressional
resolution, 22 percent of respondents chose "Jews having legitimized
the genocide claim," second only to the "efforts of the Armenian
diaspora," which came in at 44%.
Whatever else it accomplishes, the congressional resolution on the
Armenian genocide looks set to insure the ADL will have plenty of work
to do in Turkey in the months ahead.
[email protected]
Source: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1191257 295565&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Calev Ben-David , THE JERUSALEM POST Oct. 14, 2007
Abe Foxman must be feeling a little vindication these days - although
that may be of little solace to the outspoken Anti-Defamation League
national director.
Last August, when the ADL's New England chapter defied the
organization's long-standing policy not to formally condemn the
killings of Armenians by Turkish forces during World War I as a
"genocide," Foxman promptly fired regional director Andrew Tarsey.
But under pressure from other local ADL leaders, Armenian activists
and Massachusetts political figures, Foxman reversed his position,
rehiring Tarsey and calling Turkish acts during the war "tantamount to
genocide."
Still, he refused to offer support for a congressional resolution
making the same declaration. "I believe the issue should not be
debated at the US Congress. US congressmen are not historians.
Therefore, they cannot judge what happened in history," Foxman
commented last month, after meeting in New York City with Turkish
Prime Minister Recip Tayipp Erdogan.
The US Congress thought differently, with the House Foreign Affairs
Committee passing a controversial resolution last week labeling the
Turkish actions as genocide.
The political fallout has been swift and harsh, with Turkey condemning
the resolution and recalling its ambassador from Washington.
With rumblings from Ankara about curtailing cooperation with American
forces fighting in Iraq, and even threats of a large cross-border
operation against Kurdish nationalist strongholds in northern Iraq,
this situation is primarily a problem - a big one - for the US.
But it's also one, albeit to a lesser degree, for Israel and the
American Jewish leadership.
Placing a higher priority on its valuable strategic relationship with
Ankara, Jerusalem has resolutely steered clear of the "Armenian
genocide" controversy, as have traditionally, for the most part,
American-Jewish organizations such as the ADL.
"We fully understand the importance of Israel's strategic alliance
with Turkey," said one prominent US Jewish leader, "so over the years,
despite the stand on the issue taken by such individuals as Elie
Wiesel [who has publicly condemned the Turkish actions] we've given
precedence to our concerns about the security of Israel over any
feelings over the need take a moral stand on the Armenian genocide.
"Foxman was right about the substance of the issue last summer," the
leader added, "but he let the situation in Boston get away from him,
and felt he had no choice but to backtrack and accept their position."
That turnaround angered the Turks, who not only blamed the ADL for
reversing its position, but also held Jerusalem in part accountable.
Turkish Foreign Minister Ali Babacan made this clear on visit to
Israel last week, telling The Jerusalem Post, "All of a sudden the
perception in Turkey right now is that the Jewish people - or the
Jewish organizations, let's say, and the Armenian diaspora, the
Armenian lobbies, are now hand-in-hand trying to defame Turkey, and
trying to condemn Turkey and the Turkish people. This is the
unfortunate perception right now in Turkey. So if something goes wrong
in Washington, DC, it inevitably will have some influence on relations
between Turkey and the US, plus the relations between Turkey and
Israel, as well."
Unfortunately, despite the Turkish perception, Armenian activists and
their political supporters in the US were in fact not satisfied with
the change in the ADL's position, especially the continued
unwillingness of Foxman to support the congressional resolution. In
response, three towns outside Boston - Newton, Belmont and Watertown -
under pressure from those activists announced last month that they
were dropping their cooperation with the ADL's "No Place For Hate"
anti-bias program for local municipalities.
"This was really an issue of conscience," Newton Mayor Andrew Cohen
told The Boston Globe. "We certainly hope the national ADL do the
right thing."
He's liable to be disappointed. The ADL's National Commission, its
highest policy-making body, is scheduled to meet during the first week
of November to discuss the issue. According to sources in the
organization, it is likely to support Foxman's position in not backing
the resolution.
That will probably do little, though, to mollify either the Turks or
the Armenians, both of whom seem unwilling to accept any rhetorical
compromise from Jewish leaders.
Nor is this issue likely to go away. American-Armenian activists will
continue to press for wider acceptance of the genocide designation, in
large part using as their model the success of the Jewish community in
raising awareness of the Holocaust. Plans are even being laid to open
a Museum of the Armenian Genocide in Washington, modeled on the US
Holocaust Memorial Museum.
Israel's strategic relationship with Turkey is probably of great
enough value to both nations to not be immediately affected in any
significant way by this controversy. But the long-term impact of this
open wound is far from negligible.
An editorial run this week in Turkey's Today's Zaman newspaper quotes
Babacan as saying, "We have told them [the ADL and other Jewish
groups] that we cannot explain it to the Turkish public if a road
accident happens. We have told them that we cannot keep the Jewish
people out of this."
The editorial goes on: "Babacan is right. In the event of the adoption
of the Armenian genocide resolution at the Congress, there will be a
costly bill awaiting all parties."
According to an unscientific readers poll in Today's Zaman over the
weekend, when presented with a series of choices regarding which
factor is primarily responsible for the proposed congressional
resolution, 22 percent of respondents chose "Jews having legitimized
the genocide claim," second only to the "efforts of the Armenian
diaspora," which came in at 44%.
Whatever else it accomplishes, the congressional resolution on the
Armenian genocide looks set to insure the ADL will have plenty of work
to do in Turkey in the months ahead.
[email protected]
Source: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1191257 295565&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress